10 February 2011
Can a moose be used as a "beast of burden" ??
I saw the photo above at Uncertain Times and began to wonder. One's knee-jerk reaction is, of course, to assume that every odd photo is 'shopped, but reindeer have been semi-domesticated for centuries. Could you train a moose to pull loads, if you started at an early age?
I couldn't track down that photo's original source, but I did find these images of young moose in harness at Black Bear Blog:
The first shows a young moose harnessed to a carriage; it comes from Alaska History Store and is labeled "Skagway Alaska." The second moose seems to pulling either a travois or a plough. One comment at the Black Bear Blog linked to this photo -
- showing "a pair of moose, hand-raised by owner Peachy Prouden. The photo was taken at Athabasca Landing, Alberta in 1898."
Here's one more, from Tossing Pebbles in the Stream:
- where there is also a photo of a moose with a saddle on it.
So, now that we're convinced that a "working moose" is possible, what about the original photo? It is Photoshopped, as explained at this "urban legends" site, where note is made of "Chevaux d'Abitibi" ("Horses of Abitibi") on the man's jacket and the mirror-image woodpiles on the left and right covering some other item(s) in the original photo.
But it is possible.
And, if you've read this far and are still paying attention, you might move on to this Google Books link that explains why a moose's long legs give it an advantage in fleeing from wolves on irregular terrain (and other quite interesting biologic tidbits).
Personally, I like this one better:
Second addendum: Reader Spiritartartist found and posted this photo of a (quite large) moose in harness in her blog three years ago:
The moose was named "February," and the photo was taken in New Jersey in 1886; details at the link.
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
I pegged the top picture as Photoshopped because the harness is sitting too precisely on top of the moose's coat. And the bit isn't anywhere near the mouth.ReplyDelete
http://www.snopes.com is my favorite site for researching urban legends. It's far better about siting sources than about.com, although Snope's article on this particular topic is less detailed: http://www.snopes.com/photos/animals/workmoose.aspReplyDelete
A word of warning: you can get lost for days in their archives.
Shhh ... Don't tell Santa Claus ...ReplyDelete
(... you might be doing Rudolph and the others out of a job ...)ReplyDelete
I remember finding an article given to me a long time ago, by someone who found a picture I drew of a reindeer in saddle and bridle. I was unaware that other animals could be harnessed aside from horses, oxen, donkey, reindeer, and mules, etc. There are instances of people trying to ride elk, but however, most deer and animals like llamas and alpacha are unsuitable for riding mainly because their backs are more flexible than a horse's and would cause great discomfort to a rider (in fact as a tutorial for depicting people riding animals such as wolves and tigers, an artist had to point out wolves and cats alike have very flexible backs, look at a cheetah for such comparison). Plus the way an animal walks also determines the comfortability of riding on one (such as in the case of Paso Fino horse; they're the cadillac of horses). I haven't notice how a moose moves it's legs, but if it's similar to a camel's, then it would be a very bumpy ride, noting that most if not all of the pictures above are of moose harnessed to pull wagons and such, rather than riding.ReplyDelete
I've received that particular photo as an email before. I am looking for it now.ReplyDelete
I did find these links...
Stonemaven, tx for the moose dairy link; it's better than the one other that I encountered.ReplyDelete
Neat-o! I found this on youtube, pretty crazy!ReplyDelete
Years back, I posted the same photo on my blog! I also had several other posts about moose as we had one here locally in the late 1880's trained to pull a cart, called "February". He was reported to have paraded his owner through Mt. Holly, NJ, the county seat, on a most memorable political campaign.ReplyDelete
Also here is an old photo of a guy riding a moose.
I love your blog. It is all over the place and always makes me think! Thank-you!
Thanks, Sandy. I've added your info (with a link) to the post.ReplyDelete
A moose once bit my sister.ReplyDelete
hee hee, I was just planning on writing a blog about domesticated moose, my chairman at the U told me about moose riding mongols terrorizing Asia. So much so, that when the Mongols were finally defeated, the rest of Asia outlawed the domestication of moose! And the source of your top picture there comes from a pair in Alberta. When the female died, that big bull died of a broken heart. :( since this won't let me go through my wordpress id I'll sign it, kzackuslheureux.wordpress.comReplyDelete
Referring to, "I saw the photo above at Uncertain Times and began to wonder. One's knee-jerk reaction is, of course, to assume that every odd photo is 'shopped,"ReplyDelete
Yes, it has been "shopped". The stack of wood on the right is a pasted reverse image of the stack of wood on the left.
Yes I see what you are talking about the wood stack. Good call.Delete
Bottom line is that the Russians actually had a program in trying to domesticate moose as beast of burden prior to WW2. The best of their efforts assessed that only 1 in every 1,000 had the ability to be domesticated so the program was dropped.ReplyDelete