[This post is a compilation of three articles I've written over the past two months about the life cycle of the American Lady; I decided it made more sense to combine them into one megapost.]
butterflies (Vanessa virginiensis
) are not uncommon; the real challenge is to document an entire life cycle, starting with the egg. To do that, one has to locate one of the food plants for the caterpillars - Pussytoes, Pearly Everlasting, or Burdock. Here in Wisconsin there's lots of burdock, but in the early spring it's also easy to spot Pussytoes (Antennaria spp.) because they thrust their fuzzy cats-paw-like flowers above the other vegetation on long stems.
Finding the eggs is a challenge. The upright stems do have small clasping leaves, but the American Lady prefers to oviposit on the rosette of basal leaves next to the ground, and those leaves tend to be obscured by grasses and low vegetation.
The egg is tiny and well-camouflaged, because it is green and almost translucent. Most of the ones I have seen have been single, on top of the leaves, in the midline, and about a cm from the tip - like the one in the photo above. At the Butterfly Garden forum
at Gardenweb I've read reports of Ladies ovipositing on the flower stem or head, but have never seen a photo of such or found one myself; it would be a real challenge to locate an egg in that complex flower structure.
On closup view the egg looks like a little gooseberry -
- with some vertical striations that resemble the old-fashioned candy root-beer barrels, similar to those of another Vanessa (the Red Admiral), whose eggs are shown here
The photo above shows a pair of eggs on two leaves of a small pussytoes plant. After the first instar emerges, he may eat the eggshell itself:
I've not observed that process, but it's a well-known phenomenon with other species. The first instar has a semi-translucent body and is very difficult to see except for that black head. Without the aid of a macro lens, the first obvious evidence of hatching is a "scraping" of the superficial layer from the leaf:
The caterpillars of many (?most) species eat through the leaf, typically from the edge. The American Lady cat leaves a layer of cells, as can be seen when the leaf is backlit:
If the cat leaves the leaf (or is killed by a predator), the superficial lesions heal to leave small scars:
At the scraping site, the early instar also instinctively begins its classic self-defense; it creates a roof of silk above its eating site. The frass remains inside the notoriously messy "nest."
The caterpillar rarely comes out during the daytime. The later instar in the photo below is beginning to display the rather striking spines that will be more evident as it grows. When it reaches this size, it also becomes capable of actually pulling the edges of the pussytoes leaf together to make a more secure nest.
I believe this is facilitated in part by some natural curvature of the leaf, but the final product is really quite striking, and easily visible when you walk past a patch of pussytoes.
Within that nest the caterpillar continues to scrape the inner surface of the leaf for its nutritional needs. This is a leaf I unfolded from an empty "nest":
The later instar's intact nest is quite a formidable defense against the spiders and parasitic flies that plague the insect world
I find it interesting that when several leaves are stitched together, the larger gaps are filled not just with silk, but with some white patchy material that doesn't appear to be silk; I suspect it is some of the detritus scraped off the leaf surface. It almost looks like a decorative lace.
Addendum: Later in the summer I encountered this fellow, whose "nest" was comprised of only a lace-like roof. Considering his/her large size and the small size of the available leaves, I presume the cat wasn't physically able to approximate the sides of the leaves, and thus had to settle for this more open-air arrangement.
Like other photographers and butterfly enthusiasts, I've been reluctant to open these nests to get photos of the middle and late instars, because the cat invests so much energy in creating the nest, one doesn't want to disturb it. But they do sometimes wander out...
and in doing so they display their other defenses - an array of spines and hairs that are visually quite formidable.
Whether they are toxic to touch or not, I do not know (haven't tried). There is more information on the American Lady caterpillars in these three posts
at the GardenWeb Butterfly Garden Forum.
I have only a few photos of the caterpillars because as a whole I saw them very seldom. I eventually became suspicious about the lack of apparent activity and opened one of the nests…
This cat has been parasitized; I don’t know whether this occurred before I collected him, or whether the fly/wasp/whatever penetrated our screen porch and the tulle covering the container. I should have saved this specimen to see what eventually hatched, but I discarded it, so if anyone reading this can give me insight re the identity of the parasite, I would be quite interested.
The scene was replicated in a couple other nests, and a couple more were just empty, with no sign of the cat. I finally decided that some “skins” I had seen earlier and had assumed were shed during molting were probably desiccated bodies of parasitized cats.
Eventually two cats successfully formed their chrysalises on the tulle; I used a bit of dental floss to tie them to a stick for more stability:
I was at first intrigued by the striking difference in color in the two chrysalises. I’ve seen variable color in BST chrysalises and thought this was natural variability – until I happened to turn the stick so that it was backlit…
The pale chrysalis is obviously almost empty. That cat also had been parasitized, or at least had shriveled and died for some reason. That left me with just one chrysalis to complete this documentation of the cycle. I kept my fingers crossed.
The last chrysalis finally turned quite dark one evening. The next morning I moved it to my breakfast table and kept it by my side while I started the NYT Sunday crossword. I was planning to get some pix of the eclosion, but the process was of course silent and I was engrossed, so when I finished the puzzle and looked up, she already had her wings fully inflated -
A closeup of her pattern beneath the wings shows the characteristic two eyespots and the delicate “cobweb” pattern in the proximal wing. The colors combine some beautiful shades of brown and sort of a russet and a subtle blue (all these photos will supersize with a click)...
When she became restless I moved her to some rattan. Her resting pattern looked like this –
- and when I startled her with the camera she raised her forewing to display her hidden beautiful rose pattern -
Maybe it was a coincidence that she did this when I got close to her, but it seemed as though she were using the rose spot for a sort of defensive purpose to “startle” a potential predator. This was within a couple hours of eclosion, so she was still docile enough to climb onto my finger and display her upper wing pattern when I put her in direct sunlight –
The American Lady is supposed to show a characteristic small white dot inside the large orange cell by the upper wing margin. This particular butterfly didn’t have such a spot. After another hour or so in the sun she was ready to go, so I took her outside on the deck and she flew off over the treetops. BTW, I’ve been calling this butterfly “she” because of her name, but to be honest I have no idea whether this is a male or a female; I’d appreciate any information on how to make that distinction.
These are common butterflies that range coast-to-coast and Canada-to-Mexico
in the United States, and for that reason I suspect the delicate beauty of their wing patterns is not fully appreciated. Try supersizing the photos with a click...
Wow, gorgeous photo and fantastic documentation! I once kept a chrysalis in a bottle to observe the eclosion process, and was surprised to see that the butterfly fully emerged in less than ~2 mins, so I'm not surprised that you missed the process. Gotta keep a more watchful eye for next time. :)ReplyDelete
I'm not sure exactly how you'd sex a butterfly either. My guess would be that the female's ovipositor might make the rear of her body longer than the male's. That's how it's done with many insects anyway.ReplyDelete
Some butterflies have gender-specific color patterns. Male monarchs have black androconial patches on their hindwings:ReplyDelete
Awesome post. I'm sure I've seen American Ladies in my yard in Houston. I'll keep a lookout for more.ReplyDelete
FWIW, I just looked up the butterfly in Butterflies of Houston and Southeast Texas and it doesn't mention a difference in the sexes.
I stumbled upon your blog when I was looking for pics to help identify a caterpillar that at first I thought was a Painted Lady. I found it on pussytoes in my garden.ReplyDelete
I would like to link to your site in my blog if that is ok. I will check back here to see if you reply to me.
I am the anonymous who found your site and wants to link to it.ReplyDelete
I still haven't identified my caterpillar. It is eating the pussy toes, but doesn't look like an American Lady cat so not sure what it is.
Hi Kat -ReplyDelete
You never need to ask permission from me to link to my site. Most bloggers - me included - are delighted when someone links to them.
If you can post a photo of your caterpillar at some free site (like Flickr), someone will be able to help you identify it. The people at the Butterfly Gardens board at GardenWeb -
- are especially skilled in that regard.
6coI just watched some Black Swallowtails go from last instar to butterfly. 6 of my 7 caterpillars made it to pupation. 3 of my 6 chrysalises made it to become butterflies! This blog was pointed my way because of this and I really enjoyed this. The American Lady is absolutely breathtaking.ReplyDelete
Congratulations, Leahfu. Black Swallowtails are beautiful butterflies. We have three different food plants for them planted in our garden, but none have showed up to lay eggs yet. I keep hoping...ReplyDelete
I just found this blog. There are American Lady caterpillars here in southcentral Texas now. We've had freezes, one as low as below 26°. And yet these caterpillars are continuing...apparently quite cold-hardy things...some are still small! The host plant we've got is Sweet Everlasting, Gnaphalium obtusifolium. This has been a good year for that plant and there's quite a bit of it here! I've never seen these caterpillars so late in the year before.ReplyDelete
Nice find, anon. Since the leaves of the everlastings hug the ground, maybe the cats were not exposed to the colder upper air.ReplyDelete
I used to live in Dallas and visit my Dad in Weslaco, but was not a butterfly enthusiast in those years. I'm sure I missed a lot of opportunities there.
Great documentary and photography!! I'm fairly new at butterfly gardening here in Wisconsin (I've had lots of experience in Fla). I recently discovered caterpillars on my Pussytoes and Anaphalis triplinerva. This post has been both informative and inspirational.ReplyDelete
Greetings, John. I don't know whether you'll see this note, but if you do, and if you are anywhere near Madison, please consider joining the NABA group here. The SWBA (Southern Wisconsin Butterfly Association) has a website here -ReplyDelete
- and we have a field trip coming up this Saturday.
If you're a long ways from Madison, see this site -
- which posts all the sightings in the state and links to a comprehensive field guide of the butterflies of the state.
Great info! Thanks for this post, as I've not found a lot published on this butterfly and its host plants. I planted Pearly Everlastings a year ago. As I watched the plants evolve last season, they looked much like these photos, and I didn't want to interrupt the potential cat process by looking into their potential nests. Now I am sure that's what was occurring.ReplyDelete
At what point did you bring them in?ReplyDelete
The year I wrote the post I brought them into our screen porch when they were about in the second instar stage (exploring outside their nests).Delete
This year the pussytoes patch was larger and virtually every plant had a "nest" in it this spring. So I decided rather than bring any in I would just cover the patch with a wire mesh to keep birds away. That was a mistake. As the summer has progressed it has become obvious that every single one of the cats has been killed (the screen I covered the patch with didn't have a fine-enough mesh to keep out wasps. It's also likely that they succumbed to ants and spiders and other insectivores.
That is part of the great scheme of nature. During a butterfly hike a couple weeks ago I spoke with the lead researcher at the University of Minnesota's Monarch laboratory; she told me that field studies have shown 90-95% mortality between egg deposition and flyaway.
I read that american ladies have a white spot that Painted Ladies don't have. It's small and on the top side of the forwing. I don't see the spot in your picture... any clue as to whyReplyDelete
I have difficulty distinguishing American Ladies and Painted Ladies from the topside. The differences in coloration pattern are subtle and I think somewhat variable -Delete
When the ID is important (seldom), I try to view the undersides, which are distinctly (and consistently) different.
Thank you for this detailed post! Last year I planted Pussytoes on our property and now this spring, it is host to several of these caterpillars! I was searching the internet to identify them. Thank you so much!ReplyDelete
Holly, at the risk of being a "Debbie Downer", I should point out that many (probably most) of those caterpillars will fall victim to birds, spiders, and ants - despite their "nests" and spines. They are not difficult to raise in the safety of a screen porch if you want to take the time to bring some leaves to them (or plant some pussytoes in a pot).Delete