As reported in The Telegraph:
The painting, which depicts Isabella d’Este, a Renaissance noblewoman, was found in a private collection of 400 works kept in a Swiss bank by an Italian family who asked not to be identified. It appears to be a completed, painted version of a pencil sketch drawn by Leonardo da Vinci in Mantua in the Lombardy region of northern Italy in 1499. The sketch, the apparent inspiration for the newly found work, hangs in the Louvre Museum in Paris...
Scientific tests suggest that the oil portrait is indeed the work of da Vinci, according to Carlo Pedretti, a professor emeritus of art history and an expert in Leonardo studies at the University of California, Los Angeles. “There are no doubts that the portrait is the work of Leonardo,” Prof Pedretti, a recognised expert in authenticating disputed works by da Vinci, told Corriere della Sera newspaper.
Martin Kemp, professor emeritus of the history of art at Trinity College, Oxford, and one of the world’s foremost experts on da Vinci, said if the find was authenticated it would be worth “tens of millions of pounds” because there are only 15 to 20 genuine da Vinci works in the world. But he raised doubts about whether the painting was really the work of Leonardo. The portrait found in Switzerland is painted on canvas, whereas Leonardo favoured wooden boards...More details at the link.
There are further doubts – Leonardo gave away his original sketch to the marquesa, so he would not have been able to refer to it later in order to paint a full oil version. “You can’t rule out the possibility but it seems unlikely,” Prof Kemp said. It was more likely to have been produced by one of the many artists operating in northern Italy who copied Leonardo’s works.
I was looking at this image, the sketch, and some DaVinci works in some books I have. I was going to make some observations, but it occurred to me that even as a museum conservator, I am about as qualified to comment on this debate as is my house cat, I kook forward to hearing more about this.
ReplyDeleteSame here.
DeleteThough through a basic, most unqualified guess, none of the linework or shading looks as buttered out and smooth as I'm used to seeing in Da Vinci's work.
A gut level guess would be exactly what Kemp said, that it's likely to have been produced by someone copying his work.
That must be some cat! (But aren't they all?)
ReplyDeleteThat's an idea. After I'm done with readers' bookcases, maybe I should post pix of readers cats??
DeleteUm, is it just me, or does the lady have one heck of a right index finger?
ReplyDeleteLurker111
It's just you. I just looked at this article again and was going to post this same comment when I discovered that I'd posted it already.
DeleteIt's just you.
Lurker111