04 July 2019

Available at Amazon: substandard, counterfeit textbooks


As reported by The New York Times:
“The Sanford Guide to Antimicrobial Therapy” is a medical handbook that recommends the right amount of the right drug for treating ailments from bacterial pneumonia to infected wounds. Lives depend on it.

It is not the sort of book a doctor should puzzle over, wondering, “Is that a ‘1’ or a ‘7’ in the recommended dosage?” But that is exactly the possibility that has haunted the guide’s publisher, Antimicrobial Therapy, for the past two years as it confronted a flood of counterfeits — many of which were poorly printed and hard to read — in Amazon’s vast bookstore.

“This threatens a bunch of patients — and our whole business,” said Scott Kelly, the publisher’s vice president.

Dead writers get hit, too. Arthur Miller’s “The Crucible” was pirated. So was a volume of classic stories by Jorge Luis Borges. For 18 months Amazon has sold a counterfeit of Agatha Christie’s “Murder on the Orient Express” despite warnings in reader reviews that it is a “monstrosity,” dispensing with such standard features as proofreading and paragraph indenting.

Technical books, which tend to be more expensive than fiction, are frequent victims...

Amazon, which does not break out revenue or profit from bookselling or publishing, assumes that everyone on its platform operates in good faith until proven otherwise. “It is your responsibility to ensure that your content doesn’t violate laws or copyright, trademark, privacy, publicity or other rights,” it tells prospective publishers and sellers...
Counterfeit technical  books are not new.  I remember seeing mass-produced (photocopied) physiology and pathology textbooks from Asia back in the 1970s.  But I was particularly saddened by the example featured in the story, because Jay Sanford was one of my teachers.  He would be appalled both by the pirating and by the shoddy quality of the pirated versions:


More information at the New York Times.

Images cropped for size from the originals.

4 comments:

  1. These are making their way into university libraries. I recently checked out what appeared to be a Springer book on number theory that was full of those smudgy, poorly reproduced pages.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I heard a podcast recently on a somewhat related topic: cheap, substandard publishing on Amazon of public domain books. https://www.businessinsider.com/publish-books-amazon-kindle-reviews-2019-2

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. there are numerous sites that offer free ebook downloads of public domain books. archive and gutenberg are two that come to mind.

      I-)

      Delete
  3. I remember jealously guarding my Sanford guides as many copies in the hospital wards sprouted legs and walked away. I had a black vinyl slip-cover for it that was textured to look like leather. over the years, new editions kept getting thicker and thicker and eventually, my slip-cover split apart at the spine. A co-worker special ordered a large-print, spiral-bound edition that she attached to her desk with a little chain.

    ReplyDelete